When I work with a great company who makes a great hire whom everyone loves and is excited about, true confession, running a background check can feel like a waste of time. This person is so great! Everyone likes them! They are kind, friendly, personable. They have all the experience. Background checks come back clear one candidate after another…until it doesn't. So this is a cautionary tale about why we run background checks.
I recently helped a client hire a part-time bookkeeper. We found someone with exactly the profile we were looking for. She had a 12+ year career in accounting and was working successfully for a large company. Point in her favor. She wanted to lessen her work hours to be more available for her family and be there for her kids. Noble approach. Point in her favor. She was quick to respond and professional in all communication. Another point. She was meek, a bit shy, mild mannered and hit every response we were looking for in the interview. She nailed it. We made the offer. Now we needed to run background checks.
I sent her the link to fill out her information on line with the service I use for all background checks, drug tests, etc. She was quick to sign the FCRA authorization and fill out the info. I did a quick check to see that her background checks were running and the drug test was in process. Everything was on track. And then I scrolled down to see that she had left the employment verification section blank. That was weird because she had been in her last job for 7 years, good performer, liked the company, and had just left there voluntarily a week ago…or so I thought.
I called her. I told her I needed a name and phone number to verify her past employment. She kindly responded that, of course, she would get that right over to me. I did not hear back. I asked again the next day. She told me she needed to get the information. While on the phone with her, I looked up her past employer and there was a number on their website. I told her, never mind, here is the number… I will just give them a call. I said "Who should I ask for?" She said she was not sure. Weird. I quickly got in touch with the Payroll Coordinator who verified that this person's employment ended in 2021. 2021??? I told that can't be right. She just left there last week. Nope, 2021 they said again.
I went back to the applicant. She was shocked. There were tears. She insisted that was not correct (and yet she made no suggestion of taking steps to fix a mix-up). She said she would give me an email of someone she worked with who could confirm she worked there. She send me the email but I noticed it was slightly different from the company's website and published 'contact us' email.
I kept talking to the applicant giving her every opportunity to remedy the situation…clear up the confusion…tell me what I'm not understanding. Long story short, it just kept getting more weird. Her cagey behavior, delays in providing information, and unwillingness to help fix what she said was 'wrong' information from the employer, led to a conclusion that she was being dishonest, reasons unknown. We retracted the offer and avoided putting a company at risk. (Remember, we hired her to be a bookkeeper with access to bank accounts, credit cards, and highly sensitive information.)
And that is why we do background checks. 95% of the time they can feel like a formality, confirming the greatness you already know about the hire you just made. And then, 5% of the time, they provide the protection your business needs to continue thriving!
Need help with offers, onboarding, and making great hires? Let HR Managed help.
Email: hello@hrmanaged.com
Serving Greater St. Louis Area
Chesterfield Chamber of Commerce (Board Member)
SHRM-CP